U.S. District Judge David Hittner ruled Senate Bill 12 unconstitutional for the second time after the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals returned the case. The law, passed by the Texas Legislature in 2023 and effective in March, restricts certain public drag shows. All facts derive from Associated Press reporting.
No left-leaning sources covered this
“Texas’ limits on certain drag shows ruled unconstitutional again”
Read at Associated Press →No right-leaning sources covered this
Repeated federal rulings against SB 12 represent a check on state efforts to censor LGBTQ+ artistic expression through targeted restrictions on drag performances.
“Viewpoint discrimination and First Amendment protections for marginalized performers”
Texas enacted SB 12 to shield children from sexualized public performances, but federal judges have overridden legislative authority on community standards.
“State power to regulate obscenity and protect minors versus judicial overreach”
SB 12 illustrates government overreach by imposing content-based limits on expressive performances and voluntary artistic expression.
“Individual rights to speech and association against political majorities enforcing moral preferences”
All three views adopt the premise that the bill targets drag as artistic expression rather than examining whether it addressed specific sexually oriented conduct through potentially viewpoint-neutral rules.
“Overbreadth versus animus, procedural history, and lack of enforcement specifics”
Ratings by MBFC